About Playing Flute & Performing, index
My Hands, and the Rewarding Follow-up
I received a really hurtful email this morning. It was from a fellow flutist who said, and I quote:
“You have really ugly hands. Maybe you shouldn't video yourself playing flute. Or doing anything. Its [sic] no fun to watch. Ever think about getting your nails done? Try some lotion, too.”
Well, to that, here's my response ...though I neglected to mention in the video, an expert equestrian's hands:
For those who can't hear, here's a transcript of what I say:
“People comment about my hands. The brave ask about them, the concerned and well-intentioned offering me bottles of flowery-smelling lotion, presenting me gift certificates for a manicure and nail job, bringing me ointments and salves. It's true, I don't have elegant hands. I've got working hands. These hands play flute and piano, type 120 words per minute, move heavy objects, in short, do a lot of hard, physical labor. They've moved tons of hay and grain, dug post holes, strung barbed wire, carried wood and water. These are a martial artist's hands, a musician's hands, a swordwoman's hands. They ain't pretty, but I love them.”
FOLLOW-UP, December 6, 2017
The responses have been interesting and mostly positive and supportive. It's heart-warming when you find out that putting yourself on-the-line, front and center, for public response, nets you a crop of PMs via your website contact forms from people, young and adult, to whom your message holds significance to their own situations.
I think I really had no idea just how much 'what you look like doing it' would garner retaliatory remarks from the self-defined 'beautiful people' out there, not until we began posting our music videos. I really had no idea how many others had been negatively affected by people responding to their videos. (People say I don't get out much, in the real world and on the Net, and, yes, I guess they're right. :D ) Since I posted the “Dawn's Hands” video and “My Hands” blog post, though, I've got a better grasp, I think. These are just a sampling of the positive ones I've received via various contact vehicles.
“You answering that flute [expletive removed] has given my daughter new determination to start sharing her flute videos, again. Thank you.”
“I quit posting to [removed] and [removed] because people made fun of me. I still don't think I will share anymore, but I like that you spoke up for us.”
“I uploaded a video of me playing and it was like I painted hit me on my face. It made me cry. Even my friends sided with them. You made it okay. Thanks for doing that.”
There are a bunch more, but the best, so far, I think, is this one:
“You made me brave again. Maybe it's okay to be me.”
This comes all because I responded publicly to one of the critical private communications I've received about our music videos. I responded because I wanted to address the sheer mean-heartedness. I never wanted to do videos of us playing. That was my husband's desire. I just enjoyed playing, again. But it all happened. And the Net being what it is, the negativity was bound to come, bringing the desire to retreat back to my safe, text-and-image-only world.
But, why should I be ashamed of me and the parts of me that has brought me success and joy in life? Why should anyone? So I responded, publicly. I wanted it known that, no matter the criticism, nobody, not me, nor anyone else, has to quit just because somebody's mean. And, on the Net, you can very effectively respond in a way that calls the criticism out without getting into a private flame war and without publicly embarrassing the mean-spirited in front of others. Their anonymity is preserved, but their actions are front and center with public opinion, come what may, to the negative or positive, rendering judgement upon the situation.
I put myself on the line with my My Hands post and its corresponding video, and I'm happy to say that, yes, I think my goal is achieved. That these youngsters as well as the adults who have PM'd to say that my post and video has given them the reinforcement they need to be unashamed of themselves, despite negative feedback, makes it worthwhile.
And, to the person who said, “You've got a lot of chutzpah,” yes, I guess I do, and that's a good thing, I think. :D
About Playing Flute & Performing, index